CITY of SAN JUAN BAUTISTA

Planning Commission meeting:  September 4, 2007

 

MINUTES

 

Chair Garza called the meeting to order at 7:03 pm, by inviting all present to join in the pledge of allegiance to the flag.

 

Commissioners present: Commissioner Bagley, Commissioner Garza, Commissioner Spencer

 

Commissioners absent: Commissioner Cosio; Commissioner Ostrowski,

 

Staff present: City Manager (CM) McClintock, City Planner (CP) Sundt and Minutes                                      
                        Clerk Johnson

 

OPPORTUNITY FOR PUBLIC COMMENT:

 

Chair Garza opened the public hearing. With no members of the public present indicating a desire to speak to matters not appearing on the agenda, the public hearing was closed.

 

CONSENT AGENDA:

 

Consent Items

 

COMMISSIONER SPENCER MOTIONED APPROVAL OF APPROVAL OF AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING SEPTEMBER 4, 2007 AGENDA. COMMISSIONER BAGLEY SECONDED THE MOTION, WHICH PASSED (3-0-0-2), WITH THE FOLLOWING VOTE:  AYES: COMMISSIONER BAGLEY, COMMISSIONER GARZA, COMMISSIONER SPENCER; NOES: NONE; ABSTAIN: NONE; ABSENT: COMMISSIONER COSIO, COMMISSSIONER OSTROWSKI.

 

PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS ~ REQUIRING COMMISSION ACTION

 

Chair Garza indicated he could not sit for the next item due to the potential for conflict of interest (he lives nearby); consequently, the quorum was lost.

 

212 Sixth Street – New Garage (002-041-020)

 

Chair Garza announced the need for this item to be considered at a special meeting of the City Council due to lack of quorum. BY CONSENSUS OF THE COMMISSIONERS PRESENT – WITH COSIO, GARZA, AND OSTROWSKI ABSENT, STAFF WAS DIRECTED TO WORK WITH A CALENDAR FOR THE CITY COUNCIL IN ORDER TO EXPEDITE THE MATTER TO RESOLUTION.

 

300 Third Street – Subdivision (002-016-009 and 010)

 

CP Sundt gave the staff report, saying the project is designed for mixed use.

He also provided information regarding:

-         the lot size (differences in the existing and proposed)

-         submission of the tentative map

-         findings and conditions  (including remarks from the City Engineer)

-         development review sheet

-         placement of the building {Commissioners discussed the ‘fit’ on the lot}

-         design standards

-         permits required

-         right of way explanation

 

Chair Garza opened, and then closed, the public hearing as there were no persons present to address the matter.

 

COMMISSIONER SPENCER MOTIONED APPROVAL OF A TENTATIVE MAP FOR 300 THIRD STREET – SUBDIVISION, INCLUSIVE OF THE FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS AS PRESENTED.  COMMISSIONER BAGLEY SECONDED THE MOTION, WHICH PASSED (3-0-0-2), WITH THE FOLLOWING VOTE:  AYES: COMMISSIONER BAGLEY, COMMISSIONER GARZA, COMMISSIONER SPENCER; NOES: NONE; ABSTAIN: NONE; ABSENT: COMMISSIONER COSIO, COMMISSSIONER OSTROWSKI.

 

Chair Garza emphasized that the Commissioners had provided direction to staff to determine if the plan, as conceptually presented will not work, the applicant must return to the Commission for further discussion and approval. “We understand that if it will work, staff will continue work with the Applicant,” CP Sundt said.

 

Commissioner Bagley was excused for the next agenda item due to the potential for conflict of interest; consequently, the quorum was lost.

 

1 Polk Street – Sign Permit - Tops Rock Shop (APN 002-014-006)

 

Chair Garza announced that due to the lack of a quorum, this item could not be addressed at this meeting.

 

Discussion Items

 

A.  Conceptual Review of the Artisans Plaza Project – 70 Muckelemi

 

CP Sundt presented the staff report, during which he and CM McClintock noted that the project as presented at this meeting varied from that originally proposed – and further noted that both were conceptual. In-depth discussion ensued, with several issues were raised regarding the plan, including

-         parking

-         vehicle turn-around space

-         need for planned turn lanes

-         proposed height of the building

-         façade

-         environmental review need for noise analysis

-         need for retaining wall

-         exterior views for residential

 

Staff said they would continue talks with the applicant, including the myriad of changes presented in the current conceptual plan.

 

Comments and Announcements: 

 

Commissioners:

-         voiced concern that correspondence is received at meeting regarding items on the agenda. All Commissioners present felt that was inappropriate as there was not time to study the issues being addressed in a timely manner.

-         continued concerns of many Code Enforcement issues

-         new soccer fields at the Elementary School: need for walking path; CM McClintock advised the City is not involved with the construction as the school does not have to obtain a permit from the City

-         questions of a possible lot line adjustment at the Mission; CM McClintock advised this is being worked on.

 

City Manager:  

announced upcoming meetings:

-         CalTrans regarding the need for an over crossing at 156 and The Alameda, and the need for CalTrans to assume responsibility for the costs of the traffic signal

-         City Council meeting regarding parking issues down town (set for September 7, 2007)

 

City Planner:

provided an overview of the next meeting (October 2, 2007, which he described as ‘very busy’.

 

 

Adjournment:

 

ACTING ON THE MOTION BY COMMISSIONERS BAGLEY/SPENCER FOR ADJOURNMENT, CHAIR GARZA DECLARED THE MEETING COMPLETED, AND AT 8:20 P.M. SO ORDERED. 

 

 

                                                                                    ______________________________

                                                                                      Reuben Garza, Chairman

ATTEST:

 

_______________________________

Trish Paetz, Deputy City Clerk